Home


Ready-to-Bake, Delicious, Comfort Food



Pittsburgh Pot Pie – Menu

Pittsburgh Pot Pie is a small company in McMurray, PA that makes ready-to-bake, frozen pot pies and seasonal dessert pies. These pies are available for curbside pickup or delivery within a 20 mile radius of McMurray, PA or you can purchase them through the stores listed below.

Chicken Pot Pie

Our buttery, flaky crusts are stuffed with chicken and potatoes and a medley of vegetables – delivered frozen, ready-to-bake! Keep one or two on hand at all times. They make great gifts as well! They are available in a 10″ Family Size or a 6″ Personal Size.

Shepherd’s Pot Pie

Our version of the classic Shepherd’s Pie is made with beef, cheesy potatoes, and a blend of colorful vegetables, wrapped in our buttery, flaky crust on both the top and the bottom. These pies are delivered frozen, ready-to-bake. They are available in a 10″ Family Size or a 6″ Personal Size.

Seasonal Dessert Pies

We have a variety of seasonal dessert pies, including Dutch Apple Pie, Blueberry Pie, Pumpkin Pie, Spiced Apple Pie, Blackberry Pie, and Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie. These pies are delivered frozen, ready-to-bake. Go to our online store to see what we have available.



Arranging Curbside Pickup or Delivery


Curbside Pickup or Delivery Options

Note: Due to the overwhelming response, we typically have an order waiting list. Order fulfillment might be delayed up to one week and potentially longer depending on the current volume at the time of your order. If we have the pies in stock, you will be able to get those pies quickly through curbside pickup (sometimes “same day”). Delivery is available on a limited basis. If you need the pot pies delivered by a certain date, please contact me (regina@pittsburghpotpie.com) to confirm availability prior to ordering. Thanks for your patience!

Curbside Pickup – Appointment Only

We do not have a Pittsburgh Pot Pie retail location, but we can make special arrangements with you to pickup at our commercial kitchen location (details below). In order to make sure that someone is available to help you, please call (412-328-1011) or email (regina@pittsburghpotpie.com) to confirm your order/arrival.

Pittsburgh Pot Pie – Commercial Kitchen Location
Donaldson’s Crossroads
3909 Washington Rd
Suite 201
McMurray, PA 15317

Note: If you would like, you can also contact the stores listed at the bottom of the page if their location is more convenient for purchase/pickup.

Delivery Details

If you are unable to pick up your order, we might have a delivery option for you. Our standard deliver radius is 20 miles from McMurray, Pennsylvania. If you are outside of this radius and must have comfort food, we understand. Let us know where you are and we will see if we can help!

Our delivery schedule fills up quickly each week. Typical delivery times are between 6:00 pm and 8:30 pm. Once you place your order, you will receive a call/email/text message within 24 hours to schedule the delivery.


About Us


About Us

Pittsburgh Pot Pie is a small company in McMurray, PA that makes ready-to-bake, frozen pot pies and seasonal dessert pies. These pies are available for curbside pickup or delivery within a 20 mile radius of McMurray, PA or you can purchase them through the stores listed below.

Regina’s Background Story:

“I have always enjoyed pot pies, especially my mom’s homemade pot pies and dessert pies! After moving to Pittsburgh from Ohio’s Amish Country, I quickly found a small local company who made small batches of pot pies. I became a regular customer. The greatest thing about these pot pies was that I could keep one or two of them in my freezer at all times and not have to make dinner every night. It was nice to be able to pull one out for dinner and have the freshly baked pot pie aroma fill my house.

These pot pies are the best pot pies I have ever tasted. The buttery flaky crust is amazing and combined with the chicken or beef filling, it makes the perfect, easy to prepare comfort food. A couple years later, I had the opportunity to purchase the company and I didn’t hesitate!

After purchasing the company in early 2020, I reopened Pittsburgh Pot Pie’s doors on March 14th – “Pi Day”. One day later, the whole region shut down due to COVID19. I did my best to fill the demand for home baked products and arranged curbside pickups and home delivery wearing masks and gloves. Due to this increased demand, my one-person business has grown into a small team of pie makers and we are thankful for the support of our local community!

We look forward to continuing to provide delicious comfort food to the Pittsburgh region. Buy one or two pies to keep in your freezer for a rainy or snowy day or buy one as a gift for a friend.”

Regina Doty – Owner, Pie Maker

Pittsburgh Pot Pie – Hours and Locations

Open Hours

Mon – Fri – 12:30 pm – 5:30 pm Closed on Saturday & Sunday
Holiday hours vary

Location

3909 Washington Road, Suite 201
McMurray, PA 15317

Contact

Regina Doty – Owner
(412) 328-1011
regina@pittsburghpotpie.com

Pittsburgh Pot Pie is also available for purchase at the following locations:

  • The Country Store – 698 Venetia Rd, Venetia, PA 15367
  • Heritage Craft Butchers – 1784 Main St. Marianna, PA
  • Heritage Craft Butchers – 243 S Main St., Washington, PA
  • Heritage Craft Butchers – 1462 E High St., Waynesburg, PA